Beyond Traditional Metrics: How to Track Procurement Cost Savings and Calculate True ROI with the Economic Benefit Model™
Procurement leaders in higher education and the public sector are facing an evolution in how success is measured. While traditional metrics like budget variance, unit cost reduction, or negotiated discounts are important, they don’t really capture the full story of procurement activities. Today, your job goes beyond just negotiating price reductions. You must capture the total economic value of what you do to demonstrate true ROI.
The E&I Cooperative Services Economic Benefit Model™ plays a pivotal role here. The model enables procurement teams to go beyond traditional savings calculations and quantify the total economic benefit: a comprehensive, data-driven view of procurement’s true contribution.
In this post, we’ll explain how to track procurement cost savings and calculate genuine return on investment through modern frameworks to bring clarity, transparency, and strategic accountability to procurement reporting.
Why Traditional Procurement Metrics Fall Short
For decades, procurement performance was defined by one question: how much did we save? While this will always be important, it really doesn’t capture the value of the work procurement teams do every day.
A 2025 global survey of procurement leaders put cost reduction and efficiency as the top priority for 68% of procurement teams. That’s the same as it’s been for the past two years, and these two items are intricately related. Despite this focus, however, most procurement teams have a difficult time demonstrating how their work impacts institutional performance beyond immediate savings. That’s because traditional metrics measure outcomes in isolation without accounting for avoided costs or value-adding incentives. The E&I Economic Benefit Model™ focuses on total value, helping everyone understand how procurement activities result in measurable financial and operational value.
The E&I Economic Benefit Model™ (EBM) provides a structure to measure procurement success through a broader lens and produce a procurement ROI calculation, integrating three key components:
- Cost Reduction: The direct savings achieved through competitively solicited pricing or cooperative scale.
- Cost Avoidance: The expenses prevented by avoiding RFPs, reducing RFP cycles, stabilizing pricing against inflation, or streamlining supplier management.
- Incentives and Revenue: Rebates, patronage, and incentive-based returns that generate additional institutional value.
Together, you get a 360-degree view of impact to help you reduce or eliminate:
- Uncertainty about costs of key products and services
- Leaving money on the table with suppliers
- Indirect costs and administrative overhead
- Missing opportunities to drive revenue from procurement practices
This model helps you uncover hidden savings and document the total value from all of your decisions.
How to Track Procurement Cost Savings More Accurately
Tracking total value begins with consistency, defining what counts as savings and how it should be measured. You can follow a few key steps to bring structure to your tracking efforts:
- Establish a baseline: Use historical spend data, prior supplier quotes, or previous-year budgets to set a clear benchmark for comparison.
- Capture indirect benefits: Include process efficiencies, labor time saved, and avoided administrative costs such as fewer RFPs or shortened procurement cycles.
- Record incentive value: Factor in cooperative patronage, rebates, and other financial returns. These often represent meaningful contributions to operational budgets but are rarely included in traditional calculations.
By consolidating these categories within one unified framework, the E&I Economic Benefit Model™ ensures that every source of value is documented and measurable. The result is a transparent, repeatable model that helps you track value over time.
Procurement ROI Calculation: From Efficiency to Strategic Impact
When you take into account both direct and indirect costs, the procurement ROI calculation shows a more accurate picture. For example, saving a few thousand dollars on a particular purchase is good news, but not if it requires spending two to three times that amount in labor, overhead, and ad spend to develop, publish, evaluate, and award RFPs. Yet, if you’re not tracking all of your savings and costs, you won’t know that what looks like a win is really a loss.
Top-performing procurement teams understand this and apply this strategy for success, delivering a return on investment that more than doubles the average return compared to their peers. And they’re operating at a significantly lower cost as a percentage of spend. In short, high-performing procurement teams aren’t just cutting costs. They’re optimizing total value creation.
The E&I Economic Benefit Model™ helps education procurement teams bring that same level of visibility and rigor to their ROI measurement, capturing cost savings, avoided spend, and incentive-driven revenue all in one model.
To explore how data-driven frameworks like the E&I Economic Benefit Model™ can strengthen your organization’s ROI, visit the E&I Cooperative Services website.
